It’s been about 5 weeks since Jonathan Barber joined me live at 8020 HQ.
In re-listening to the interview, one thing popped out:
In a back-and-forth about flow, Barber says (and I’m paraphrasing), “I tell my students to commit to a ‘mistake’. Don’t shy away from it. Embrace that serendipity.”
I’m listening to this just days after hearing, for the umpteenth time, the famous Tony Williams clinic in which he says “I didn’t want to hope; I wanted to know it would work.”
“Oooooh,” I thought. “The plot thickens.”
I love then great players say seemingly-contradictory things, because unraveling how they can both be right reveals a lot about the topography of their field.
How could Tony and Jonathan both be right?
Maybe Tony was talking about technique, whereas Jon was describing ideas.
Maybe one is appropriate advice for beginners (i.e. “to you it looks like chaos, but I’ve worked hard to be able to harness that chaos” - Tony, paraphrased), and the other is for more advanced players (i.e. “once you have basic control over your ideas, you can miss opportunities by being too perfectionistic”).
It caused me to remember some of my own experience teaching, and giving different advice for different situations. To one student with decent control, who voiced a fear of “messing up”, I recommended he “try to mess up”. The idea, I suppose, being that if we pre-defang that fear, you neutralize it, and then we can focus on more fine-grained things.
To others, I’ll come from more of the Tony angle - guard rails are important, because you want to build outward from a lexicon of ideas that, to apr Tony, you’re pretty sure will work.
Regardless, I found Jonathan a fun thought-partner in describing many aspects of his approach to the drums, and the right person to answer a bunch of questions I’d been wrestling with.
He helped me have more confidence in following my own ideas, instead of feeling like I need to learn every chop I see.
His was a welcome voice in saying he aims to impress his bandmates, not other drummers.
At any rate, intros last: Jonathan popped on my radar a couple of years ago in a video from a live performance, in which he struck me as one of the more original-sounding young jazz drummers. To learn that his mentor, Eric McPherson, was another fearless innovator and progenitor of his own unique lane, was no surprise.
It’s this approach that Jonathan describes bringing to his own teaching, and it was a pleasure to have the opportunity to pick his brain.
Hope you enjoy!
